Time to Stop Playing with Our Balls and Strikes
This debate about baseball in Israel has gone just about far enough. Perhaps we have become so insensed by the current state of affairs in Israel, or have been so numbed by a corrupt system that remains in power, that we have decided to turn our attention to an easier target: recreation and entertainment.
Recreation is good. Professional entertainment bad. Fine. Case and point. I like baseball, and just may see a game before this summer is out, because I still retain many habits from a former life in the United States, like surfing the internet past my bedtime.
But here at Kumah, we are supposed to be shining Israel in a positive light wherever possible, pointing out areas critical for the growth of this nation, and pushing American aliyah.
I am quite worried that this hit and run on America's pasttime now in Israel, runs counter to the goals of our organization.
American Jews love American sports. This phenomenon is a little difficult to understand, even for myself who to this day thinks of the ballpark anytime I smell a freshly cut lawn.
Moving to Israel is hard. Real hard. Don't let these Aliyah junkies tell you otherwise. Most American olim consciously and unconsciously look far and wide to seek out the comforts of the old country here in our new habitat. Whether it is Hellman's mayonaise or a trip to Ikea, these creature comforts help us feel at home in our elevated environs.
I am quite afraid that this battery on baseball--a familiar face to many olim who feel as if they have left many wonderful things behind to begin a better life--might make future olim uncomfortable.
I worry that potential olim, and others reading this blog may begin to think that we have struck out swinging. We don't need to attack anything and everything that runs counter to the religious ideal. We need religious and non-religious Jews who like baseball to come make Aliyah, and help strengthen our nation.
There are a lot of problems in Israel and within American Jewry. Baseball, for better or for worse, is not one of them.
Look at the coaches signs, there is a lot of work to do here. I think we should step up to the plate, and try to hit a home run on some serious issues in this country, before our society gets picked off trying to steal a base.
And I also think that for those of us who don't like professional sports--in a land where soccer goons riot, and a basketball team routinely wins the European championship--paying any additional mind to this baseball league is simply giving more attention to another business started in Israel with private American investment.
9 Comments:
At July 12, 2007 at 6:27 PM , Anonymous said...
Your well-crafted comments are so superfluous. I love baseball and it pleases me enormously that I could enjoy that in Israel as well. You're awesome for making aliyah and I hope I will too, and I appreciate your statement that it is hard. By its very nature, it has to be hard. And all the "the land is bought with struggle" is very nice but doesn't help much when the struggle is real tough. So I hope your struggle lightens--as for me, I think it's great and another way to talk to American Jews about Israel. Is there really an Ikea there? That's wonderful too. Kol tuv, Ellen
At July 12, 2007 at 10:46 PM , גיל רונן said...
Real Jews sacrifice sheep, not flies.
At July 12, 2007 at 11:53 PM , Yishai said...
Re: "There are a lot of problems in Israel and within American Jewry. Baseball, for better or for worse, is not one of them."
The IBL is one of the first visible products of the Aliyah Revolution - and it has drawn lots of excitement and attention. It sends a message - this is the culture that American Jews are bringing with them.
When the Temple Institute rebuilt the Menorah they had a dilemma - where should it be placed? They decided in the end to place it smack in the middle of the Cardo, that it, the old Roman thoroughfare that runs through the heart of the Old City in Jerusalem. Why did they choose this place and not somewhere close to the Kotel? The Temple Institute wanted to send a message saying: "You Romans took our Menorah, burned our Temple, and exiled our people - now we, the Jewish people are back, but where are you?!"
The Menorah therefore is a symbol of our revolt against Greco-Roman culture. But in an interesting twist of fate, the Israel Baseball League, with the tacit backing of American Orthodox Jewry, has taken that very Menorah and put it on the uniforms and logos of the Modiin Miracles, a competitive athletic team made up of foreigners. The irony is great.
It is important to hash out this issue because it will help shape and direct the future of American Aliyah. The creation of culture is paramount when we talk about state-building. It may be that the IBL is good for Aliyah, and in the end will be a tool to help bring the Jewish people home. It may also be that we will have to spend lots of time and energy to eradicate the vestige of foreign culture that has seeped into our blood in 2 millennia of Galut.
At July 13, 2007 at 3:57 AM , Pinchas said...
I don’t see any irony at all with the Modiin Miracle. Jewish identity is firmly intact. It’s an Israeli team, with an Israeli name, watched by Israeli fans, while eating Israeli food, played on an Israeli field, with tickets paid for in Israeli currency. Alex, you are absolutely right! Thanks for making the argument so eloquently. Those that have strong opinions against spectator sports in general should take it out on someone else but not on American Olim. Now buy me some peanuts and crackerjacks!
At July 13, 2007 at 7:22 AM , Yishai said...
RE: "I don't see any irony at all with the Modiin Miracle. Jewish identity is firmly intact. It's an Israeli team, with an Israeli name, watched by Israeli fans, while eating Israeli food, played on an Israeli field, with tickets paid for in Israeli currency."
With that kind of logic many other things are also part of Jewish identity: gambling, prostitution, drugs, eviction, chilul Shabbat - basically anything done by Israelis in Israel with Israeli currency - is Jewish.
Not everything that Jews do is Jewish. Not even everything Orthodox Jews do is Jewish.
(By the way - any comment on Rav Moshe Feinstein's take?)
RE: "Those that have strong opinions against spectator sports in general should take it out on someone else but not on American Olim."
American olim are the ones who are making a big noise about the IBL: articles are being written in every major media outlet including A7, TT, and our very own Kumah. In other words, it's being shoved down our throat. When you make something so public you subject yourself to criticism.
Not everyone agree with the pro-IBL crowd. Many people have written me on this topic and feel as strongly as I do. For example:
Baseball ...
I believe as Malkah on this point ... I've developed promotions for one of the major league teams over the last several years - great folks! ... professional baseball is about numbers (money) and this message is received by the fans, which is the beginning of the erosion of a traditional value system. An almost imperceptible chink in the 'value judgement' armor of our traditional beliefs. ... When we travel to Nicaragua, Honduras, Dominican Republic, etc the love of playing the game of baseball becomes the chase of money and fame ... rather than building strength in their communities, the ball players leave their communities (never looking back once they make it out in most cases - I can't think of any 'current' Robert Clemente's in professional sports today. ... Children grow up distracted by the 'larger than life' attraction of what they perceive to be idols - not their fathers, brothers or HaShem. ... Children look at what is 'out there' (reality or not) and become disillusioned with what they have in their lives, and eventually leave once they become old enough.
It would have been nice to have seen tax dollars spent on Children's Intramural Baseball programs to balance this out, giving them the satisfaction of building their own JEWISH Baseball Teams competing with other JEWISH Baseball Teams learning the value of working for what you have.
Those Jews who may choose to make Aliyah only due to Baseball have misplaced priorities.
Best regards,
Laurie
At July 13, 2007 at 7:35 AM , Pinchas said...
For that matter I have had many people ask me in person why Kumah is picking on Baseball...
Re: Rav Moshe Feinstein, ZT"L I have not been able to look it up inside to see the whole letter. It is well known that many of his letters are often interperted by both sides of an argument as holding thier way. One thing though from what I saw he could only be refering to an American pro-game... the IBL environment is far different. Because all of the crowd is Jewish.
And yes, Jewish identity is maintained in all aspects of life in Israel. And no one is making Aliyah just for baseball! But it's still great that we can get out to the ballpark for a game or two.
I know Yechiel took some pictures so you get an idea of what it's like and I'm looking forward to seeing them.
Shabbat Shalom!
At July 15, 2007 at 1:19 AM , Pinchas said...
Interesting bit of Trivia quoted on Hirhurim. http://hirhurim.blogspot.com/2004/10/baseball.html
"According to Dr. Jeffrey Woolf, R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik was a Red Sox fan."
At July 15, 2007 at 2:44 PM , Alex said...
By the way, I really should have added the following in my post. It is a very important point.
In the same vein that we don't need to use so much of cyberspace knocking Israeli baseball, I also don't see the point in going out of our way to PRAISE Israeli baseball.
A post of interest, such as: "I went to the game..." could be great, but after that--come on.
I don't see why the OU's Torah Tidbits needs to adopt the IBL, and I certainly don't want to see multiple stories about it on Arutz Sheva, or on this blog!
OU TT... OUT T... OUTT! And thats an inning, folks.
At July 15, 2007 at 2:46 PM , Alex said...
Gil...
In your mode of thinking, let's hope Israeli MKs start to shag flies instead of... Well, just ask Chaim Ramon.
:) Is this a family blog?
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home